Head-to-Head Proxy ComparisonVerified Public Specifications (Oct 2026)
LunaProxy vs ProxiesThatWork
Side-by-side comparison of LunaProxy and ProxiesThatWork across supported proxy types, residential pricing per GB, datacenter & ISP pricing, geographic coverage, protocols, session rotation, authentication, platform features, and pros & cons.
Provider 1Cataloged
LunaProxy
ResidentialDatacenterISP
Historical commercial proxy network named in Google Threat Intelligence Group investigation of the IPIDEA network on January 28, 2026; commercial operations are discontinued and original domains are inaccessible.
Residential / GBNot available
Starting Price / IPNot available
Geographic Coverage195+ Countries
ProtocolsHTTP, HTTPS, SOCKS5
VS
⇄ SwapProvider 2Cataloged
ProxiesThatWork
Datacenter
Budget bulk datacenter proxy provider offering high-volume HTTP/HTTPS proxy packages ($3/mo for 150 IPs, $20/mo for 1,000 IPs, $50/mo for 2,500 IPs; ~$0.02/IP effective) with IP allowlisting, unmetered bandwidth, and automated health monitoring.
Residential / GBNot available
Starting Price / IPFrom $0.02 / IP
Geographic Coverage1+ Countries
ProtocolsHTTP, HTTPS
Network Coverage
Supported Proxy Network Types
Side-by-side availability across Residential, Datacenter, Static ISP, and Mobile proxy pools.
| Proxy Network Type | LunaProxy | ProxiesThatWork |
|---|---|---|
Residential Proxies (Rotating & Sticky) Household ISP-assigned IPs supporting automatic rotation and sticky sessions | ✓ Supported | Not available |
Datacenter Proxies (Dedicated & Shared) High-speed IPv4/IPv6 cloud server subnets for bulk concurrency | ✓ Supported | ✓ Supported |
ISP / Static Residential Proxies Static consumer ASN-registered IPs hosted on server backbones | ✓ Supported | Not available |
Mobile Carrier Proxies (3G / 4G / 5G / LTE) Cellular gateway IPs routed through carrier CGNAT pools | Not available | Not available |
Pricing Comparison
Calculate Monthly Costs →Residential Pricing per GB, Datacenter & ISP Rates
Verified pricing across residential bandwidth per GB, datacenter and static ISP per-IP/bandwidth plans, and minimum account outlays.
| Pricing Category | LunaProxy | ProxiesThatWork |
|---|---|---|
| Residential Starting Rate (per GB) | Not available | Not available |
| Published Pricing Summary | Service Discontinued / Defunct • Named in Google Threat Intelligence disruption of IPIDEA network (Jan 28, 2026) • Original domains inaccessible • Historical rate cards archived for reference | Bulk Datacenter Packages from $3.00 / month (150 IPs, ~$0.02 / IP effective) • 1,000 IPs for $20.00 / month • 2,500 IPs for $50.00 / month • Custom Bulk Quotes Available • Unmetered Bandwidth • Disputed 3-Day vs. 7-Day Refund Policy |
| Datacenter Proxy Pricing | Historical Datacenter Proxies: Previously marketed from ~$0.80 / IP / month on shared and dedicated datacenter pools (historical reference only; not active) | Bulk Datacenter Proxies (Monthly Packages): 150 IPs: $3.00/mo ($0.02/IP effective, $3.00 minimum entry) • 1,000 IPs: $20.00/mo ($0.02/IP effective) • 2,500 IPs: $50.00/mo ($0.02/IP effective). Monthly recurring billing; unmetered bandwidth within fair-usage limits; IP allowlisting authentication; static IP lists for the billing term. |
| ISP (Static Residential) Pricing | Historical Static ISP Proxies: Previously marketed from ~$3.00 / IP / month across dedicated residential ASN subnets (historical reference only; not active) | Not available |
| Mobile Proxy Pricing | Not available | Not available |
| Starting Rate per IP | Not available | $0.02 / IP |
| Billing Structure | discontinued | Monthly Subscriptions |
| Minimum Outlay / Deposit | Not available | $3.00 |
| Accepted Payment Methods | Credit Card (Historically)Crypto (Historically) | Credit CardStripe |
Technical Capabilities
Locations, Protocols, Session Rotation & Authentication
Side-by-side comparison of geo-targeting granularity, supported connection protocols, sticky session durations, authentication methods, and platform tooling.
| Technical Dimension | LunaProxy | ProxiesThatWork |
|---|---|---|
| Geographic Coverage & Targeting | 195+ Countries (Historical vendor claim; service discontinued) | United States (multiple regional datacenter nodes); accessibility tested across 100+ global locations; custom regions via quote |
| Documented Country Count | 195+ Countries | 1+ Countries |
| Supported Protocols | HTTPHTTPSSOCKS5 | HTTPHTTPS |
| Rotation & Sticky Sessions | Historically offered per-request rotation and sticky sessions up to 90 minutes | Static bulk datacenter IP lists (IP:Port) delivered per subscription term; does not feature per-request rotation, residential session sticky hold, or mobile network targeting |
| Authentication Methods | Username / PasswordIP Whitelisting | IP Whitelisting |
| Documented Platform Features | CRITICAL STATUS: Named in Google Threat Intelligence Group disruption of IPIDEA network (January 28, 2026)Google coordinated disruption alongside Cloudflare, Spur, and Lumen Black Lotus LabsGoogle Play Protect automated enforcement against deceptive proxy SDKs (Castar, Earn, Hex)Allegations and technical findings attributed to Google civil litigation and threat intelligenceOriginal domain (lunaproxy.com) is defunct and completely inaccessible as of October 2026No common ownership or operational continuity established with similarly named luna-proxy.comHistorical proxy portfolio: Rotating Residential, Unlimited Residential, Static ISP, and DatacenterStrictly excluded from Mobile category (no verified historical mobile cellular product)All active commercial pricing is marked Unavailable / Discontinued across ProxyReviewsExcluded from active provider directory, rankings, category counts, and cost calculator | Bulk Datacenter Capacity: Tiered monthly packages delivering 150, 1,000, or 2,500 shared datacenter IP addressesLow Entry Threshold: Starter tier available at $3.00/month for 150 IPs (~$0.02 effective price per IP)Unmetered Bandwidth: No metered gigabyte billing or per-GB data caps on active datacenter subscription tiersIP Allowlisting Authentication: Access authenticated by whitelisting client IP addresses directly in the control panelAutomated Health Verification: Provider tests proxies continuously and reports system state on status.proxiesthatwork.comHTTP/HTTPS Protocol Support: Native compatibility with web scraping frameworks and HTTP client librariesCustom Enterprise Quoting: Bespoke volume packages and regional options available through dedicated sales quotesStrict Classification Scope: Classified strictly under Datacenter proxies; no Residential, Static ISP, or Mobile poolsDocumented Refund Policy Discrepancy: Highlights conflicting 7-day marketing claims versus 3-day binding Terms of Service |
| Integration Tools & Clients | PythonNode.jsGocURL | PythonNode.jsGocURLPlaywrightPuppeteer |
| Ranking Placement | Not available | Not available |
| Official Documentation Source | https://cloud.google.com/blog/topics/threat-intelligence/disrupting-largest-residential-proxy-network ↗ | https://www.proxiesthatwork.com/pricing ↗ |
Trade-Offs Breakdown
Verified Pros & Cons: LunaProxy vs ProxiesThatWork
LunaProxy
Rank #null✓ Verified Strengths (Pros)
- Historically provided high-affordability residential bandwidth starting below $1.00/GB on volume packages
- Previously featured a dedicated desktop proxy client and browser extension for session and IP management
- Offered diverse historical product types including Rotating Residential, Unlimited Residential, Static ISP, and Datacenter
- Historical documentation supported wide protocol compatibility spanning HTTP, HTTPS, and SOCKS5
✕ Documented Limitations (Cons)
- CRITICAL: Disrupted by Google Threat Intelligence on January 28, 2026 as part of the IPIDEA proxy network ecosystem
- Google investigation identified proxy supply chain reliance on deceptive SDKs turning consumer devices into unwitting exit nodes
- Commercial service is completely defunct; original domain (lunaproxy.com) is inaccessible and no longer resolves
- Similarly named domains (e.g. luna-proxy.com) lack verified common ownership or operational continuity with the original service
ProxiesThatWork
Rank #null✓ Verified Strengths (Pros)
- Extremely accessible entry pricing: $3.00/month for 150 IPs and $20.00/month for 1,000 IPs (~$0.02/IP effective rate)
- Flat-rate monthly billing with unmetered bandwidth and zero metered per-GB consumption charges
- Simple setup via IP allowlisting, avoiding credential parsing issues in multithreaded scrapers
- Public operational status monitoring tracking API and network segment availability at status.proxiesthatwork.com
✕ Documented Limitations (Cons)
- Shared bulk datacenter IP architecture: IPs are shared across users, making them unsuitable for sites with strict bot-detection (Cloudflare, Akamai)
- Direct contractual conflict between marketing page (advertised 7-day guarantee) and official Terms of Service (3-day conditional defect refund)
- Strictly Datacenter only: does not provide Residential, Static ISP, or Mobile cellular networks
- No SOCKS5 protocol support, no IPv6 addresses, and no automatic per-request IP rotation
Selection Verdict
How to Choose Between LunaProxy and ProxiesThatWork
Selecting between LunaProxy and ProxiesThatWork depends on the proxy network types, billing model, and session duration required by your workflow:
When to Choose LunaProxy
Cybersecurity research, legal case analysis, threat intelligence evaluations, and academic studies examining proxy industry supply chains and law enforcement disruption operations.
Look elsewhere if: Active web scraping, data collection, or any business production workflows requiring live, stable, and legally compliant commercial proxy infrastructure.
When to Choose ProxiesThatWork
High-volume scraping on lenient target sites, SERP tracking, open directory aggregation, price monitoring on non-protected endpoints, and automated testing tasks where cheap bulk IPv4 datacenter proxies with unmetered bandwidth are required.
Look elsewhere if: Accessing websites protected by sophisticated anti-bot systems (Cloudflare, Akamai, Datadome), sneaker or ticket drops requiring residential/ISP ASNs, workflows requiring SOCKS5 or IPv6, or operations demanding unconditional 7-day refund guarantees.
Compare LunaProxy or ProxiesThatWork with Other Proxy Providers
Explore alternative head-to-head matchups from our verified proxy catalog.
⇄ Swap Order (ProxiesThatWork vs LunaProxy)LunaProxy vs 2Captcha ProxyLunaProxy vs Bright DataLunaProxy vs OxylabsLunaProxy vs DecodoLunaProxy vs SOAXLunaProxy vs WebshareLunaProxy vs IPRoyalLunaProxy vs HProxyLunaProxy vs MassiveLunaProxy vs The Social ProxyLunaProxy vs ProxyGuysLunaProxy vs SquidProxiesLunaProxy vs BuyProxies.orgLunaProxy vs MyPrivateProxyLunaProxy vs Oculus ProxiesLunaProxy vs ProxyOmegaLunaProxy vs HydraProxyLunaProxy vs SimplyNodeLunaProxy vs TabProxyLunaProxy vs ProxyWingLunaProxy vs ABCProxyLunaProxy vs 922 S5 ProxyLunaProxy vs PYPROXYLunaProxy vs Proxy302LunaProxy vs IPBurgerLunaProxy vs ASocksLunaProxy vs Lightning ProxiesLunaProxy vs Storm ProxiesLunaProxy vs Live ProxiesLunaProxy vs NetNutLunaProxy vs Proxy-CheapLunaProxy vs PacketStreamLunaProxy vs NimblewayLunaProxy vs AstroProxyLunaProxy vs FloppyDataLunaProxy vs FroxyLunaProxy vs MarsProxiesLunaProxy vs ThordataLunaProxy vs GeonodeLunaProxy vs InfaticaLunaProxy vs ProxyrackLunaProxy vs ProxyScrapeLunaProxy vs NodeMavenLunaProxy vs Proxy-SellerLunaProxy vs EvomiLunaProxy vs RayobyteLunaProxy vs ProxyEmpireLunaProxy vs DataImpulse